Skip to content

Why raising your insurance excess is usually the cheapest lever

The arithmetic takes two minutes and almost nobody runs it. It tells you exactly how many claim-free years it takes for a higher excess to pay for itself.

Insurance pricing has one lever that is entirely in your control and rarely examined: how much of a claim you agree to pay yourself.

In the UK, Australia, India and much of the Commonwealth this is the excess. In the United States it is the deductible. The mechanism is the same — the amount deducted from any claim payout, or paid by you before cover applies — and so is the trade-off. A higher excess means a lower premium, because you are absorbing more of the small claims yourself.

Most people accept whatever the default is. That default is set by the insurer, and it is not chosen with your interests in mind.

The calculation

It is one division.

Take the annual premium saving from raising the excess. Divide the additional exposure by that saving. The result is the number of claim-free years needed for the change to pay for itself.

An illustrative example. Suppose raising your excess from $500 to $1,000 reduces your premium by $120 a year.

  • Additional exposure: $500
  • Annual saving: $120
  • Break-even: 500 ÷ 120 ≈ 4.2 years

So if you claim less often than roughly once every four years, the higher excess leaves you better off. If you claim more often than that, it does not.

Most drivers and most households claim considerably less often than once every four years. Which is why, for many people, the higher excess is the better arrangement — and why insurers rarely make it the default.

Run it on your own policy

  • Get quotes at two or three excess levels, changing nothing else
  • Additional exposure ÷ annual saving = break-even in years
  • Compare that against how often you have actually claimed
  • Confirm you could pay the higher excess tomorrow, in cash

The condition that has to hold

The arithmetic is only half of it. The other half is liquidity.

You must be able to pay the excess immediately, without borrowing. An excess you cannot cover converts a manageable event into a crisis, and if you end up putting it on a credit card at a high rate you have destroyed the saving and then some.

The honest rule: only raise the excess to a figure you could pay tomorrow from savings without it hurting. If that figure is small, keep the excess small and find the saving elsewhere. This is one of the places where the right answer genuinely depends on your circumstances rather than on the maths.

The second-order effect nobody mentions

There is an argument for a higher excess that has nothing to do with the premium.

In many markets, making a claim affects future pricing — through the loss of a no-claims discount, a claims-history surcharge, or simply being re-rated at renewal. The effect can persist for several years. Which means a small claim is often not worth making at all: you receive a modest payout now and pay more than that back over subsequent renewals.

If you would not claim for a small amount anyway, you are paying for cover you will not use. A higher excess prices that reality honestly and reduces your premium accordingly.

A low excess mostly buys the ability to make small claims. If you would never make a small claim, it is buying very little.

Where to check before changing anything

A few specifics that catch people out.

Compulsory versus voluntary excess. Motor policies frequently have a compulsory excess set by the insurer plus a voluntary amount you choose. The figure that matters for a claim is the total of both, and quotes do not always make this obvious.

Separate excesses by peril. Home policies often carry different excesses for different causes — escape of water, subsidence and storm damage commonly attract higher figures than the standard. Raising the general excess may not touch these.

Per-claim, not per-year. On most policies the excess applies to each claim. Two incidents in a year means paying it twice.

Young or additional drivers. Motor policies frequently impose extra excesses for drivers under a certain age. Check the total that would apply to whoever is actually driving.

Excess protection add-ons. Sold as a way to reclaim the excess after a claim. Run the numbers before buying: the annual cost against the excess amount and your claim frequency. Frequently it reintroduces the cost you just removed.

Doing it properly

  1. Get quotes at several excess levels, holding everything else constant. Do not compare across different insurers at the same time — you want to isolate one variable.
  2. Calculate break-even at each level.
  3. Cap the excess at what you can genuinely pay from cash today.
  4. Check the peril-specific excesses on home cover, and the compulsory-plus-voluntary total on motor.
  5. Make sure the cover itself is still what you need. A cheaper premium on inadequate cover is not a saving.

The wider point

The excess is unusual because it is a lever that reduces cost without reducing the cover that matters. You keep protection against the events that would genuinely damage your finances, and you stop paying for protection against the ones you would absorb anyway.

That said, insurance decisions carry real consequences if you get them wrong, and policy wording varies considerably between products and jurisdictions. If you are unsure what a change means for your cover — particularly on home, health or liability policies — check with the insurer directly, or speak to a regulated broker or adviser before making it.

Cutting Costs